Professor Hilary Cass, author of the independent review into gender identity services for children, said she could not support the draft legislation on conversion practices, arguing that its current wording risks "serious unintended consequences" for parents and therapists.
Concerns over the bill's language
Cass warned that the way the draft bill is phrased could capture ordinary conversations and therapeutic activities in ways not intended by ministers. She said the potential breadth of the definitions used in the draft legislation raises the prospect of parents and clinicians being inadvertently criminalised for interactions that are not attempts to change or suppress a young person's identity.
Legislative context and aims
The government says the proposed law is intended to outlaw practices designed to change or suppress a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity. Supporters argue a clear legal ban is needed to protect LGBT+ people from harmful and coercive interventions. Critics, including some clinicians and campaigners, have urged changes to ensure the law targets abusive practices without impeding legitimate medical care, parental guidance or consensual therapeutic work.
Political and policy implications
Cass’s public distancing from the draft bill adds pressure on ministers to clarify the text and the scope of criminal liability. Her intervention is likely to sharpen debate in parliament and among professional bodies about how to draw the line between coercive conversion practices and accepted standards of care for children and young people with questions about their gender identity.
Next steps
Ministers will have to consider whether to revise the bill’s definitions and safeguards in response to concerns from experts and stakeholders. Any amendments are expected to be central to forthcoming parliamentary scrutiny as lawmakers seek to balance protecting vulnerable people from harm with preserving lawful, consensual clinical and familial interactions.