Jobseekers and campaigners are pressing employers to give feedback to candidates after applications and interviews, saying many people are left without any explanation when they are turned down.
Those advocating for change argue that feedback would help applicants improve their performance, reduce uncertainty and make the hiring process more transparent. For many candidates, especially those applying repeatedly for roles, receiving specific reasons for rejection could be useful for addressing skills gaps or interview technique.
But the idea of making employers provide individual response to every applicant raises practical questions. Businesses cite the time and administrative burden of offering personalised feedback to large numbers of candidates, and some warn that comments could be misinterpreted or open firms to legal risk.
Discussion has therefore focused on what a balanced approach might look like. Options mentioned by employers and commentators include brief standardised rejection messages, automated systems that provide basic reasons for non-selection, or tailored feedback for shortlisted candidates. Whether governments should mandate responses, or simply encourage better practice, remains a matter of debate.
Proponents of mandatory feedback say it could promote fairness and improve candidate experience, particularly for people from underrepresented groups who may disproportionately suffer from opaque hiring processes. Opponents caution that imposing legal requirements could increase costs for employers and complicate recruitment, especially for small firms and organisations managing high applicant volumes.
As the conversation continues, some employers are experimenting with clearer communications at different stages of recruitment, while others maintain that resources are better spent on improving job adverts and candidate screening up front. The broader question — whether regulators should force firms to reply to every applicant — is likely to depend on how policymakers balance the interests of jobseekers with the practical realities of running recruitment at scale.