Geneva — Negotiations at the United Nations aimed at securing a negotiating mandate for a legally binding treaty to regulate the use of autonomous weapons collapsed in the early hours of the morning after a week of intensive talks.
All-night discussions failed to overcome objections from the Russian delegation, described by some participants as a form of filibustering, and the meeting broke up just before 5am without the consensus needed to begin treaty negotiations.
The talks took place under the auspices of the UN’s Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons (CCW) in Geneva. Although an overwhelming majority of states at the conference were reported to support launching formal negotiations toward a binding international agreement on AI-enabled and autonomous weapons, the CCW’s requirement for consensus meant delegates were unable to adopt the stronger mandate.
Faced with the lack of unanimity, the conference instead agreed to a much weaker option. The outcome falls short of the negotiating mandate campaigners and many states had sought and marks a setback for efforts to establish international rules specifically addressing the development and use of autonomous systems in conflict.
Diplomats and observers said the failure to secure a negotiating mandate leaves the timetable and format for future work unclear. The debate over how best to control emerging AI-enabled weaponry is likely to continue at future CCW meetings and in other international fora, as states, experts and civil society contend with both technical and legal challenges posed by autonomous systems.
The talks underscored the deep divisions among states over the scope of restrictions and the mechanisms for producing a binding treaty, and highlighted the procedural hurdles inherent in multilateral disarmament negotiations where consensus is required.