Kushner says Russia would accept 'NATO-like' security guarantees for Ukraine; experts express scepticism

Former White House adviser Jared Kushner has said Moscow would accept a NATO-style security arrangement for Ukraine, a suggestion analysts say is unlikely given the alliance’s mutual-defence commitments and Russia’s longstanding objections to NATO expansion.

Former White House adviser Jared Kushner has claimed that Russia would be willing to accept a “NATO-like” security pact for Ukraine, a proposal that has prompted immediate scepticism from analysts familiar with the region and alliance politics.

At the centre of the debate is NATO’s Article 5, the alliance’s cornerstone pledge that an attack on one member is considered an attack on all. Article 5 creates binding mutual-defence obligations among member states, a status Ukraine does not currently possess.

Analysts contacted in response to Kushner’s comments said extending NATO-style guarantees to Ukraine would be politically and practically complex, and in many respects unprecedented. Some described the suggestion that Russia would agree to such terms as stretching plausibility, with one analyst saying the idea "stretches credulity."

Sceptics note that the phrase "NATO-like" covers a range of possible arrangements and that the implications of any mutual-defence guarantee would depend on difficult negotiations over scope, verification and enforcement. They added that without clearer detail about what Kushner meant by the term, it is hard to assess whether the proposal reflects a realistic diplomatic path or an aspirational formulation.

The comments have revived discussion about what forms of security assurances could be offered to Ukraine short of full alliance membership, and about the limits of diplomatic confidence-building with Moscow. Observers say any proposal that moves beyond declaratory language toward binding commitments would require broad international agreement and a willingness by all parties to accept significant constraints and oversight.

For now, the claim has prompted questions rather than answers: supporters of enhanced guarantees argue they could deter further aggression, while critics insist any arrangement described as "NATO-like" would need to confront the political realities of collective defence and the resistance such a shift would likely encounter.