Budget 'dupes' for luxury Christmas gifts gain traction as cost-of-living squeeze bites

Cut-price versions of high-end seasonal products — from supermarket candles to cheaper cashmere jumpers — are becoming mainstream as shoppers hunt savings during the cost-of-living crisis. The trend, amplified on social media, is prompting debate over value, originality and fairness.

A festive bargain hunt

As household budgets remain under pressure, shoppers seeking present inspiration are increasingly opting for lower-cost alternatives to well-known luxury items. Products that replicate the look, scent or feel of pricier lines — often labelled online as “dupes” — have moved from niche internet conversations into mainstream retail, with supermarket chains and value brands offering stand-ins for seasonal bestsellers.

High-profile examples have helped the phenomenon gain attention. Fans of large botanical candles with citrus and spice notes have compared the White Company’s £95 “winter indulgence” candle — which some customers call the “scent of Christmas” — with a markedly cheaper £25 version sold by Aldi. Other categories, from cashmere jumpers to skincare and homewares, are seeing similar parallel products drawing interest.

Social media platforms, in particular TikTok, have accelerated the trend by circulating side-by-side comparisons and shopping tips that steer consumers toward cheaper alternatives. For many buyers, the attraction is straightforward: achieving a similar aesthetic or scent at a fraction of the price during a season when discretionary spending is squeezed.

Brands, shoppers and the ethics of imitation

The rise of dupes has prompted discussion about where to draw the line between fair competition and copying. Supporters say affordable versions democratise access to desirable goods and allow people to take part in seasonal rituals without overstretching finances. Critics argue that close imitations can undercut original designers and creators, raising questions about intellectual property, craftsmanship and where value lies.

Retailers that produce lower-cost alternatives say they are responding to demand, while established brands stress quality, provenance and the premium associated with their names. The conversation also touches on sustainability: some consumers view buying less expensive or mass-produced items as wasteful if they do not last, whereas others consider accessible price points necessary in difficult economic times.

Market implications

Analysts and industry commentators say the mainstreaming of dupes reflects broader shifts in consumer behaviour brought on by economic uncertainty and the growing influence of online communities. For retailers, the surge in demand for affordable seasonal gifts presents both an opportunity to capture budget-conscious shoppers and a challenge to differentiate offerings.

As the festive season approaches, the debate over whether buying or selling copies of luxury goods is “fair” is likely to continue. For now, many shoppers appear to be weighing cost, perceived quality and brand values as they decide how to make their homes and gift lists feel suitably festive without breaking the bank.